Category Archives: Saltwater

Double Haul

With Joe Mahler

Sanibel Island Diaries Part 2

Read Part 1 – The Schminnow

The spring in New Jersey has been one of the coldest on record, we did not get the ice conditions I had hoped but once spring hit, the thermometer did not rise. Heading down to Florida for some saltwater action seemed just the cure for my post winter malaise. This is our second trip down to Sanibel Island, last year we headed down to celebrate Mark’s 30th, this year it is a party for Mark and Jourdan. On the debut trip I was able to hook a Gulf Toad Fish on the fly and some nice fish on bait, this year I committed to Fly Fishing only.

MKFF Assembled
MKFF Assembled

Saltwater fly gear is considerable weightier than the Sage 4wt, my primary weapon against Trout. You also have to practice making longer casts, or at least achieving proficiency with throwing a Schminnow in the forty to fifty feet range. In order to make sure we used proper technique, I contact Joe Mahler, one of the top fly-casting instructors in the United States. Brenton, Jourdan and I were set up for several hours of lessons.

Joe Mahler beach side instruction.
Joe Mahler beach side instruction.

Joe is an excellent and patient instructor, he worked with Brenton on his double haul, Jourdan and I on our rod death grips. To achieve long casts, I had fallen victim to the fallacy that you need to exert your whole body. In reality, letting the rod do the work does the trick for a perfect shooting cast. These lessons set us up nicely for dock light fishing a few nights later.

Casting Practice
Casting Practice

After half an hour casting in the grass, we were anxious to follow the rest of the guys out on to the beach. For perfect conditions on the Gulf of Mexico, you need very little to no waves; something akin to glass is perfect. According to Mark, Beach fishing is generally better towards the summer and peaks in October. That being said, we wanted to taste salt and Joe indicated, though conditions were not perfect, tourists had caught some large Saltwater Fish by braving the choppy seas.

Jourdan gets the skunk out!
Jourdan gets the skunk out!

Fish cruising the beach will be located in the trough which runs along the beach in between the first sand bar or on the sand bar’s far side drop off. The perfect cast will land in front of an incoming wave, that wave will not be so large as to develop a white froth. Joe discusses keeping your fly “in the zone” in this very informative article http://www.joemahler.com/#!__surf-sand-and-snook.

The Largest Stickleback Ever
The Largest Stickleback Ever

 

The beach cruising fish prefer flies that mimic the Glass Minnow and other small, semi-translucent bait-fish living in the trough. A good way to locate bait-fish is to follow the birds. Mark is very helpful by carrying his cast net everywhere along the beach. Throw the net out real quick and you get an immediate picture of the subsurface bait-fish school’s size and coloration.

Mark and Dave Cast Netting
Mark and Dave Cast Netting

The day ended well, a quick lesson and all the newly minted Saltwater Fly Fisher people caught a fish. Mine was a Stickleback but a large one. I later found out, like most Ocean fish, they have terrible spikes. Do not touch them or get stung…

Sanibel Gulf Shore Moonrise
Sanibel Gulf Shore Moonrise

Don’t worry, the big feesh are coming out to play…

Part 3 – Dock Lighting for Snook

Early Morning Hunting

Not the best morning for hunting on the flats
Not the best morning for stalking the flats
Tailing Bone
Tailing Bone

I woke up really early and wanted to get some time on the flats before Jess got up.  The skies were overcast and the wind was whipping, not the ideal conditions; however, I still wanted to get out and find some tails.

Mini Puff Hook: Size 6 Thread: Danville 210 Eyes: Small Beadchain Body: Orange Chenille Wing: Calf tail mixed with grizzly hackle and Krystal Flash
Mini Puff
Hook: Size 6
Thread: Danville 210
Eyes: Small Beadchain
Body: Orange Chenille
Wing: Calf tail mixed with grizzly hackle and Krystal Flash

I went to the small section of the town flats that has some white sand.  The sand would provide a little relief trying to spot cruising shadows.  The low tide conditions would also allow tails to break the surface.  I tied on a size 6 Mini Puff and went to work.  Within 50 yards of the shore, I came across a pack of tailing bones.  I fired off my first cast of the day, and it was too close for comfort.  The pack of bones scattered in every direction.  Luckily, within another 50 yards was another pack of tails.  This time I took my time getting into an optimal position.  The pack was working into the wind at the edge of the sand and the turtle grass.  I paralleled them at 50 feet away making several casts to the edge of their group.  One of my casts landed softly right into the middle of the pack, and I was convinced that it was going to spook the entire group.  However, the pack continued to feed, I began to work my fly, and I felt the tug of a bonefish.  A strong strip set started a great fight.  After about 5 minutes I landed him, snapped a quick pic, and got my line reorganized.  Upon immediately turning around, I saw around 20 bones cruising my way.  I made one quick false cast, and my fly landed right in their path.  The lead bone of the pack slightly spooked, but he calmed down and the entire pack kept coming towards my fly.  Small twitches of the mini puff enticed a fish in the back of the pack.  A nice run and the fish was ready to be landed.  Both fish were in the 6-7lb class.

Going into your backing never gets old
Into the backing
Fish on
Fish on
Ready to be landed
Ready to be landed
First Bone
First Bone
Second Bone
Second Bone

After I caught those two, all signs of bonefish were gone.  I decided to wade back towards shore.  I found one more bone tailing tight to the shore.  I snuck my way into position and made several presentations into his vicinity; however, it was not meant to be, and I eventually spooked him.  I was on the flats for about 90 minutes and decided it was time to head home.  I went home to find Jess still sleeping.  It was a great start to the day.

Haunted by ghosts
Haunted by ghosts

Follow the Mud Trail

Morning on the flats
Morning on the flats
IMG_1162
Bahamian flag

With a full moon tonight, the tides have been extremely exaggerated at both high and low. One might think to just walk further out to find the bones during extreme low tide; however, that is not the case. The bones I have been seeing are all in ankle deep water, and these are in the 7-10lb class. Sometimes, if you are looking into the glare, all you will see is a “torpedo” wake coming at you. The low tides have also allowed me to see more trails of mud from feeding bonefish. Today, I successfully followed several mud trails to tailing bonefish.

Doc Hall's Tailing Shrimp Thread: Pink 210 Danville Eyes: Medium Beadchain Wing: Tan craft fur with two grizzle saddle hackles mixed with krystal flahs
Doc Hall’s Tailing Shrimp
Hook: Size 6
Thread: Pink 210 Danville
Eyes: Medium Beadchain
Wing: Tan craft fur with two grizzle saddle hackles mixed with krystal flash

My first attempt to a tailing fish was refused.  So was my second.  I decided that my size 6 bonefish scampi was not doing the trick today.  The night before I had tied up a fly designed for large and highly pressured bonefish, Doc Hall’s Tailing Shrimp.  It’s a very simple pattern I tied in size 6.  I decide to give it a go.  I found another large tailing fish, and it took three separate presentations before the tailing bonefish noticed my fly.  I saw him finally turn towards my twitching shrimp pattern, I dropped it, and the fish’s nose went into the turtle grass. I felt the tug, and a quick strip strike sent the bonefish off into a panic.  The fish had 3 nice runs ranging from 50-100 yards.  I knew this was bigger then my fist bonefish just by how long it took to land.  After about 7 minutes, a nice 7-8lb bonefish was at hand.  After I released the fish, it was only about 30 minutes until dead low tied and I didn’t see any more mud trails or tails poking through the surface.  It was a great morning of stalking the flats and I can’t wait to do it tomorrow!

The released fish
The released fish
A large arbor reel with a solid drag will help you handle the long runs bonefish make
A large arbor reel with a solid drag will help you handle the long runs bonefish make
Beautiful starfish
Beautiful starfish
Crystal clear water
Crystal clear water

Good luck to the rest of the MKFF crew going down to Sanibel Island!